"Just kidding..."
After Ian Fraser, a journalist, Mail & Guardian columnist (Fraser's Razor has long been a must-read) and a blogger, suggested killing South African president Thabo Mbeki, the paper hosting his blog entry pulled it and he was visited or telephoned by heavies from the state security apparatus (the police, military intelligence and the National Intelligence Agency).
Fraser appeared somewhat perplexed by the authorities' reaction. In his original, "...deeply felt attempt to creatively and artistically form a morally and socially persuasive Argument..." our intrepid blogging journalist wrote (material lifted from Jo'blog):
I don't have this reaction with everyone, but Mbekhi (sic) really has what they call in Afrikaans, a 'moer my gesig' - I mean he looks like an extra crispy unwiped bottom that's found a suit and stubble to disguise itself in. And his vice president Zuma - I have to admit, looks very much like those creepy old guys you see in bad '70's gay Swedish porn, begging for someone to urinate on them.This was back in May sometime, before Mbeki fired Jacob Zuma as his deputy owing to his ties to convicted criminal Schabir Shaik. I've not read the rest of the blog entry and so cannot comment on it. However, if the above is a fair sampling of the whole, hmm... Or as Jo'blog asks, "Dude, are you on crack?"
Fraser defends his position well, offering a lengthy dissertation on Swiftian satire and social / political activism using art as a medium. I would, however, suggest to our hot-water blogger that, for lessons in satire of any kind, he might do far worse than availing himself of any number of the Happy Tutor's diverse and creative services; pain is always a pleasure at Wealth Bondage.
Fraser allegedly has the support of the Freedom of Expression Institute (FXI), an organisation that feels his case merits it (and, coincidentally, shares much of its history with the Mail & Guardian). As he puts it, the FXI "...believes in my right to have expressed myself." I'm sure it does Ian. More, "...they feel its (sic) a freedom of speech issue." Feeling, feelings, feelings...
Look, I feel I'm giving Ian Fraser a hard time here and I don't really wish to. But, c'mon, if you live by the sword, be prepared to die by it. Explaining his satire, Fraser draws an analogy (I'm not correcting grammar or spelling here—this was clearly written on the run):
If a child is walking, and begins to approach a dangerous cliff edge, (and is seen as being clearly in danger.) You yell a warning. Is it sane to consider punishing the person who yells at the child, to step away from the edge?No, Ian, it's not, but yours is a poor analogy. Look, much as I admire Mbeki and hope we can wangle him a third term, I've had my differences with the guy. Early in 2002, reacting to our slow introduction of an AIDS strategy, I entitled a blog entry Fuck Thabo? Not a Chance.
Although I felt no threat, I did feel the need to explain that header in August of that year, using reasons similar to yours. "Now this is, after all, Africa and we do not malign our leaders lightly. But AIDS is not a subject to be treated lightly and Thabo Mbeki, who represents those leading the country, the country as a whole, and me, will not get off lightly."
I'd say such a heading is more appropriate to your analogy. Let me ask you a hypothetical question. Before boarding a flight from Jo'burg to Cape Town, would you test airport security by jocularly claiming to have a bomb on you? Be it serious, satire or delirium, the state has a duty to investigate material calling for the death of public or any other persons, especially when backed by ad hominem verbal assaults (even then, Thabo's alleged thin-skinned reaction to criticism does not come into it).
In short, were you not tapped on the shoulder by the authorities, they'd not be doing the work for which we pay them—and we'd have real cause for concern. So, yeah, if you in any way indicated the death of the president might be what one could consider a good thing, you screwed up. Admit it. Such an admission will, when all is said and done, add to your lustre as a blogger, a professional and a hard man to boot.
Any blogger should follow the advice given Ian by fellow blogger Jay and visit the EFF's recently published Legal Guide for Bloggers. More, they should read Donna Wentworth's introduction to it at Corante and follow the links.
Frank Paynter points to others (including Denise Howell, The Happy Tutor, our Chief Blogging Officer, David Weinberger and Halley Suitt) publicising the guide, which Donna—no stranger to hijacking, hence the analogy above—describes as "...a collection of FAQs aimed at helping the average blogger understand her rights in the face of legal threats that most people don't even understand."