From Madame Levy of La Vache Qui Lit
Yesterday, after much consideration and consultation with a few blogging friends, I decided to try and get in touch with Stormhoek and get some answers to some of the questions a lot of people have concerning Stormhoek and the South African Wine Industry in general since Hugh MacLeod seemed both unable and unwilling to answer any questions we had.
Not being known for my tact, everyone was begging me not to be asshole-rude as I rounded up questions from a number of people. You know who you are.
First I tried the number that Chris Rawlinson had left in my comments here. It had nothing to do with the reality of the number in South Africa which I eventually called and got a machine. I didn't leave a message and decided instead to call the UK number provided on the Stormhoek blog. I got through to someone whose name I understood as Rocko. I explained who I was (just some blogger and citizen) and that I would like to speak with Catherine Monahan (who had left a comment on my blog) or anyone else that could answer some questions I had about Stormhoek, as Hugh MacLeod had suggested I do. After putting me on hold for a couple of moments I was told that everyone was out to lunch and that I should call back in an hour. It was 3:45 pm UK time.
I then tried the correct South African number again and got Graham Knox on the line who gave me his cellphone number and suggested I call him in 30 minutes. In the meantime I re-called the UK number and was told that although they were now back from lunch, Catherine Monahan was unavailable as she "was at a tasting". I asked if there was anyone else I could speak to and was told no. No reason was given by the person I was speaking to, who was a real cunt in the UK sense of the word. I have it on tape. Called back Graham Knox who was stuck in traffic going back to the farm and although the line was bad we made an appointment to speak at 6pm.
By this time I was wondering whether they were taking the piss. I knew that the UK people were definitely taking the piss and were most likely getting pissed at their "tasting".
For all Hugh's posturing and touting of blogging and bloggers and his stealing and misinterpretation of the Cluetrain and pretend willingness to open "conversation", I still believe he divides people into two categories: Important People Who Matter and Insignificant Asshole Losers who have nothing to offer him. If you take a good look at his "cartoons" I think you will see this theme explored again and again. The people at the UK office seem to have adopted this same world view. They remind me of this horrible North London middle class prick that one of my asshat Harvard going cousins married. A real asshole. Dying to get into the Groucho Club. Taste this, fuckers.
It was six. I called the number Graham Knox had given me. He answered. We could hear each other better now and I explained who I was (or wasn't), and asked him if I could ask him a few questions. I was upfront about my run-ins with Hugh MacLeod and didn't try to pretend to be anything other than what I am. I told him the only reason I started getting interested about all these South African wine issues was because of the incredible pr push MacLeod had done on his wine.
Graham Knox was kind, gracious, lucid, calm and insightful. He answered every question thoughtfully and mindfully.
He employs 11 people on the farm. Four in management type positions and 7 workers. The workers have adequate housing and are paid a higher wage than other workers in the area and although Graham says it's a living wage and one with which his workers can support their families, he feels it is still not enough. They do not use mechanical harvesters, the terrain making it impossible and it's something he wouldn't do anyway. It's necessary for the grapes he uses to be picked by hand.
The South African government provides no healthcare for anyone. He has a plan that covers everyone who works at the farm and a medical aid worker who comes from a nearby village each week to deal with regular checking in on general health issues. If someone is seriously ill or been injured, he takes them to his doctor in Wellington.
When I asked him how he deals with anyone who has a substance abuse problem he told me that there's been two workers who were alcoholic and he brought them to a clinic run by some women's charity where they received treatment. One recovered, one couldn't. Two people in 9 years. No way is any alcohol available for consumption on the farm.
There are some families who live on the farm. There are some babies that have been born there, including Graham's own grandchildren. The school is being refurbished as there are more kids now. Not one of the children suffers from fetus alcohol syndrome.
When he first arrived, (9+ years ago if I remember correctly - I have to re-listen to the tapes - note: Graham is Australian and didn't grow up in SA.) not one worker could read or write and all had trouble counting and dealing with money. Now everyone is literate and some of the kids have gone on to university. He doesn't believe in the patriarchal system and said that was one of the hardest problems at the beginning, trying to try and change that mindset amongst the employees (partly due to so many years of colonialism).
He is a fascinating man, kind, forthright, intelligent and well read. He is ready to laugh. We went on to talk about some non-wine related subjects that we share a common interest in.
I would certainly tell my older daughters to tell their dirty vegan hippy UK student friends that the white's ok for them and the red and rosés are fair game for anyone else. Graham emailed me last night recapping the conversation and I look forward to continue exchanging reading suggestions and conversation.
To wit:
Thank you for the opportunity to meet a questing and inventive mind.
Life is both interesting and fun.
Till we talk again,
Best wishes
Graham
There was one point in his life when he could of chosen to shut down (as a human) but he chose to open up. He is an inspiring example for me and makes me realize just how fucking weird this world is. What are the chances? Or the odds, as Tree Shapiro might say.
I have tapes of the conversation and will tweak the sound a bit (Graham's voice needs to be louder and mine less) and put them up sometime next week so you can see for yourself. There is much I am not covering here including his views on the KWV, apartheid, the situation in South Africa in general and how he met Hugh and why he decided to work with him.
Lest you think I've gone completely over the edge, I still think MacLeod is a HUGE asshole who needs to get fucked badly (take a good look at his vagina and penis "witty cartoons" and ask yourself why he asks himself why he can't find love or sex) and those pretentious toffs that work at the UK office can go fuck themselves.
Tasting, my ass.
How to tell the difference between a human and a pr parrot.
Leslie Winer
I've been rough on South African bloggers of late, but it's their own fault. New to blogging — five years after Ev Williams and Blogger took it to stratospheric heights, most do not offer much at all. And hey, as a blogger only by default — my occasional post merely affords me the title, I'm not climbing into or blaming anybody here. It's just that it's all been said and it's all been done.
And, so it seems, continues to be done.
By foreigners.
Like Leslie Winer.
This story started and stopped with our Madame Levy (heavily backed by artillery, field guns, and machine-gun nests strategically posted by Jeneane Sessum and Frank Paynter, two of the finest bloggers of the old school — see my blogroll for further shining exemplars).
The above entry — lifted verbatim from Leslie's site and with which I wholeheartedly align myself, leads back through the links to the arrogant intransigence of the Idiot Macleod and amounts to as fine a lesson in blogging as anybody's likely to receive. This is what it's all about. And although I know Jeneane is probably champing at the bit to put further pertinent questions to Stormhoek's Graham, whom I'm sure would happily answer them, it's as complete a rout of blogging naysayers as I've seen (more on that subject later).
Macleod's job, no doubt, is quite safe. Were he NOT such an arsehole, Stormhoek — the type of vineyard we so desperately need in this country, would not have garnered such further positive publicity. I'm sure the Gaping Void appreciates the irony of the idiocy accorded him.
Many thanks to Graham Knox for clearing up so much so effortlessly. And especial thanks to Leslie for expending the time, money, and effort to obtain the answers to questions many of us have recently been asking.
And fuck you, pradoc.